Justin Theroux & Jesse Bradford

   

Justin Theroux - who wrote Tropic Thunder, acted in The Ten, and will be directing Zoolander 2 - is a jack of all trades. He also looks sort of like Jesse Bradford, who played Eliza Dushku's brother in Bring It On. 

Sharp noses + big black eyebrows + jawbone = lookalikesies

Mikaela from ANTM & Blair's Primary Minion on Gossip Girl

 

Mikaela Schipani from the most recent season of ANTM looks strikingly like Penelope (Amanda Setton), Blair Waldorf's primary minion. Next stop, Nelly Yuki lookalike. ALL ABOARRRRD!!!!!

Matthew Settle & Ian Harding

 

THE GOSSIP LOOKALIKES KEEP COMING! I met Josh's good friend Ian last week, and besides being a nice and great guy (and a great actor), he also looks like Rufus from Gossip Girl. You may know Ian from his statutory turn in Pretty Little Liars - he plays Ezra Fitz, one of the liars' teacher-boyfriend. 

Could you imagine if he joined the melty cast of Gossip Girl? I guess they'd bring back Brittany Snow to play Lily van der Woodsen because she played her in the backdoor pilot of Lily's Teenage Years: The Shelved Show. But I bet I could come up with someone who looks more like Kelly Rutherford than that. 

Still to go: Chuck, Nate, Jenny, Vanessa, Lily, Eric, is that it? Please send in lookalike candidates if one should strike you!

Leighton Meester & Minka Kelly

    

 Soon I will find lookalikes for the entire Gossip Girl cast. And then they will put on their own show and it will be all melty and weird. Except for Minka Kelly, of course!

You might already be familiar with Leighton Meester and Minka Kelly as lookalikes - they're in a new SWF movie called The Roommate together, after all - but luckily for me, that doesn't mean I can't post it! Lindsey Hayes Kroeger is credited as the movie's casting person on imdb, but I wonder whose idea it was originally to put the two girls together. It might have been Kroeger, but it might've been someone else entirely. Blake Lively, perhaps?

Actually, considering Minka Kelly's Serena-esque position on Friday Night Butts, I'd say we have another GG hybrid on our hands. Except instead of beauty/sphincter control, Minka would have received her coloring from Blair and her Everyone-Is-Always-In-Love-With-Me-And-Only-Me social status from Serena.

If Natalie Dreyfuss and Minka Kelly were the movie Twins, I think we'd know who got the Arnold Schwarzenegger genes.

Blake Lively & The Girl from Glory Daze (Natalie Dreyfuss)

A very good friend of mine wrote for the late TBS hit, Glory Daze. It was an hour-long comedy that followed a group of lovable frat pledges in the fall of 1986. Tim Meadows was in it. It was awesome.

The preppie pledge had a preppie girlfriend played by Natalie Dreyfuss. Her character was prim and uptight, perhaps the antithesis of Serena van der Woodsen, but Natalie Dreyfuss the actress looks just like Blake Lively. Also, her character acted as if Serena and Blair had a baby together and the baby got Serena's looks and Blair's sphincter tension. Congratulations, you two!

Evan Peters (from The Office) & Penn Badgley

Evan Peters played the intern in the season premiere of The Office this year (at least I think it was the season premiere) - you know, the one Michael Scott spanked. I think he looks like Penn Badgley, of Dan Humphrey fame. They both have black demon eyes.

UPDATE 12/6/11: Evan Peters is getting famous now! AmHorSt, you weirdo.

Gena Rowland & Blake Lively

    

This is a picture I took with my cameraphone of Gena Rowlands in A Woman Under the Influence and a picture of Blake Lively. I'm not really sure where this would go, since I don't really see a Gena Rowlands biopic starring Blake Lively going into production. But the similarity - it's uncanny!


Well which is it?!